On October 25, the 2026 Halloween Spirit jury met. The jury consisted of 2025 winners Robert and Jessica Van Dyke and their son William, Natalie Wooten and daughter Lucie, volunteer Lindsay Wasson and son Ari, and coordinator Jessica Campbell.

The winners were 5509 Shooters Hill and 10955 Keys Ct.

Winners received a yard sign to display during the Halloween holiday season, a gift card, and an invitation to be on the 2027 Halloween Spirit Jury.